Судебные источники публичного права зарубежных стран

решение как юридический акт
Часть 2. «Кейсы»: США, Великобритания, Франция, Германия
Часть

3. Институциональный подход: организация публичной власти/основные права человека.

затрагиваемой в судебном акте), факты (фабула), правовая проблема, аргументы сторон,

правовая позиция суда + позиция автора – не менее 3 аргументов со ссылкой на различные библиографические источники;

0,5* Отекущий + 0,3* Оауд + 0,2* Осам.работа
Результирующая оценка :
Орезульт

= 0,6* Онакопл + 0,4*·Оэкз/зач

1. Judiciary on the conquest of power
Does it

a truly constitutional power or just one of the governmental functions (like army)?
Whether the judicial power is compatible or not with democracy? How the political questions should be treated by judges?
Chapter 2. Models and scope of judicial review
Chapter 3. National judiciary vs international courts

constitutional power or just one of the state functions?
Whether

the judicial power is compatible with democracy when the people is a source of all power of government?
How the political questions should be treated by judges?

"executive," and "federative”.
The legislative branch must to be supreme, while

the executive and federative functions-internal and external affairs, respectively- are within the control of the monarch

the judiciary power be not separate from the legislative and

executive.
Were it joined with the legislative, the life and liberty of the subject would be exposed to arbitrary control; for the judge would be then the legislator.
Were it joined to the executive power, the judge might behave with violence and oppression.
There would be an end of everything, were the same man or the same body…. to exercise those three powers, that of enacting the laws, that of executing the public resolutions, and of trying the cases of individuals

ne sont que la bouche qui prononce les paroles de

la loi, des êtres inanimés, qui n’en peuvent modérer ni la force ni la rigueur.
Maximilien de Robespierre: Ce mot de "jurisprudence" doit être effacé de notre langue. Dans un Etat qui a une constitution, une législation, la jurisprudence des tribunaux n'est autre chose que la loi

three, but 2 basic functions of the State: creation and

application (execution) of the law. In particular, courts exercise the legislative power when they declare the laws to be unconstitutional ones